Hate speech in ukrainian internet space: religious context
PDF (Ukrainian)

Keywords

mass media
religious topics
Internet resources
hate speech
information confrontation
stereotypes

How to Cite

Kozyryatska, S. (2019). Hate speech in ukrainian internet space: religious context. Obraz, 3 (32), 87-97. https://doi.org/10.21272/Obraz.2019.3(32)-87-97

Abstract

Introduction. Recently in the Ukrainian media space there are a lot of info texts on religious topics; however, a special attention should be given to the problem of hate speech use in such texts, as repetition of certain messages that employ negatively colored or offensive lexis in relation to denominations is an indicator of influence on public opinion which can provoke aggressive public mood. Relevance of the study. The aim of this paper is the study of peculiarities of using hate speech in info texts on religious topics represented in the Ukrainian online space. It includes, in particular, monitoring of the Internet in order to detect those secular and denominational resources that employ expressive means of hate speech in headlines or info texts on religious topics, as well as the study of lexical, stylistic, structural and other peculiarities of hate speech and discovery of reasons for using it. Research methods. The research is grounded on the information approach; the method of academicliterature analysis was used for general exploration of the subject, for defining the level of theoretical study of such aspect of religious journalism as the use of hate speech by secular and denominational mass-media in reports on religious topics; methods of analysis and generalization – to distinguish the expressive means of hate speech that are used in the religious segment of the Internet space, and to determine the causes of their application. Results. The following reasons for hate speech use have been defined: 1) with the aim of influencing public opinion, i.e. forming negative image of a confession, and humiliating its status; 2) with the aim of making web headlines more ardent by means of expressive lexis use, which, in its turn, is capable of provoking readers’ interest and attracting new visitors to the web-site. There are such particularly the appeal to political stereotypes, as well as the use of politically-marked words and political slang, jargonisms, vulgarisms, dysphemisms, stylistic lowering that secure the desired expressive effect. The importance of a communicator’s status, that gives more value to a message, has been highlighted. Usually the use of hate speech is grounded on binary opposition ‘friend-or-foe’. Conclusions. The academic novelty of this research is determined by singling out the peculiarities (lexical, stylistic, structural, etc.) of hate speech in the religious segment of the Ukrainian online space and by discovering the reasons for using it. A prospect for further research is the study of communication between church and state in the Ukrainian media.

PDF (Ukrainian)

References

1. Boiko, A. (2016) «The church and politics in the Ukrainian media space (2014–2016)’’, Kyiv Orthodox Theological Academy, available at: https://www.kpba.edu.ua/publikatsii/statti/2268- tserkva-i-polityka-v-informatsiinomu-prostori-ukrainy-2014-2016-rr.html (access April 20, 2019)

2. Depo.ua. (2018) «Hundiaiev’s loyalists threat with break-off with Patriarchate of Jerusalem», available at: https://www.depo.ua/ukr/svit/gundyayivci-grozit-rozrivom-i-zyerusalimskim-patriarhatom-20181016854044 (access December 25, 2018)

3. Demchenko, O., and Tolokolnikova, K. (2017) «Hate speech»: has it decreased in 2016? A survey. Part 2», Detector.media, available at: https://detector.media/infospace/article/121981/2017-01- 04-mova-vorozhnechi-chi-pomenshalo-ii-v-2016-mu/ (access December 25, 2018)

4. Demchenko, O., & Tolokolnikova, K. (2017) «Hate speech»: how not to overemphasize either avoiding it or appropriate using it during the war? A survey. Part 3», Detector.media, available at: https://detector.media/infospace/article/122037/2017-01-08-mova-vorozhnechi-yakne-absolyutizuvati-ani-ii-unikannya-ani-pravomirnogo-vikoristannya-pid-chas-viini/ (access December 24, 2018)

5. Razumkov centre (2018) «Trust of Ukrainian citizens to social institutions: results of sociological study», available at: http://razumkov.org.ua/uploads/socio/2018_06_press_ release_ua.pdf (access January 26, 2019)

6. Pervyj Zaporozhskij (2018) «Whom the gods would destroy they first make mad. Metropolitan of Zaporizhzhia Luka hysterically reacts to the Tomos», available at: http://1news. zp.ua/zaporozhskiy-mitropolit-otreagiroval-na-tomos/ (access January 16, 2019)

7. Depo. Zaporizhzhia. (2018) «The Zaporizhzhian priest of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church – Moscow Patriarchate promises to ‘easily and phlegmatically’ destroy enemies», available at: https://zp.depo.ua/ukr/zp/zaporizkiy-svyaschenik-upc-mp-obicyaye-prosto-ta-spokiynoznischuvati-vorogiv-20180109705569 (access February 5, 2019)

8. Zik. (2018) «Kaspruk: The Russian language and the Russian church are the main instruments of the ‘Russian world’ aggression in Ukraine», available at: https://zik.ua/ru/ news/2018/08/06/kaspruk_russkyy_yazik_y_tserkov__osnovnie_ynstrumenti_agressyy_ russkogo_1380459 (access January 18, 2019)

9. RISU. Religious information Service of Ukraine (2018) «Every fourth Ukrainian trusts the church», available at: https://risu.org.ua/ua/index/all_news/community/social_ questioning/70827/ (access January 26, 2019)

10. (2015) «Hate speech and media: international standards and approaches». Kyiv, Ukraine.

11. Pravmir (2014) «Can a Christian be a nationalist?», available at: https://www.pravmir. ru/mozhet-li-hristianin-byit-natsionalistom/ (access January 26, 2019)

12. Union of orthodox journalists (2017) «Can a nationalist become a Christian», available at: https://spzh.news/ru/zashhita-very/44422-mozhet-li-natsionalist-stat-khristianinom (access January 17, 2019)

13. Union of orthodox journalists (2017) «To Huzar’s death. Whom have Uniate leaders served and are serving», available at: https://spzh.news/ua/istorija-i-kulytrua/43086-na-smertguzara-komu-sluzhili-i-sluzhat-uniatski-lideri (access January 17, 2019)

14. Union of orthodox journalists (2017) «What have Ukrainian schismatics of Kyiv Patriarchate and nationalists from “Right Sector” agreed about?», available at: https://spzh. news/ru/chelovek-i-cerkovy/43577-o-chem-dogovorilis-ukrainskie-raskolniki-kievskogopatriarkhata-i-natsionalisty-iz-pravogo-sektora- (access January 08, 2019)

15. Raskolam.net (2018) «Right Sector» clamors for passing to temples of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church in Kherson region to the jurisdiction of Philaret’s supporters», available at: http://raskolam.net/?s=%D1%84%D1%96%D0%BB%D0%B0%D1%80%D0%B5%D1%82 %D1%96%D0%B2%D1%86%D1%96&lang=ru (access December 04, 2018)

16. Relihiino-informatsiina sluzhba Ukrainy (2016) «Pro-Kremlin “Orthodox Journalist Union” comes to the attention of the Ministry of Internal Affairs», available at: https://risu.org. ua/ua/index/all_news/community/religion_and_policy/64151 (access November 20, 2018)

17. Takeinfo.net. «Cruel aggression from radicals against Moscow Patriarchate is observed in Rivne region, diocese claims». available at: http://takeinfo.net/news/view/proti_moskovskogo_ patriarhatu_na_rivnenschini_proyavlyatsya_jorstoka_agresiya_radikaliv_-_zayava_parhi (access December 25, 2018)

18. Razumkov centre (2019) «Level of trust to social institutions and electoral orientation of Ukrainian citizens», available at: http://razumkov.org.ua/napriamky/sotsiologichnidoslidzhennia/riven-doviry-do-suspilnykh-instytutiv-ta-elektoralni-oriientatsii-gromadianukrainy-2 (access April 3, 2019)

19. Savonchak, V. Ya. (2011) «Hate speech: discussing the concept», Visnyk Kharkivskoho natsionalnoho universytetu imeni V.N.Karazina. Seriia: Sotsialni komunikatsii, available at: http://www-philology.univer.kharkov.ua/nauka/e_books/visnyk_968/content/savonchak.pdf (access May 17, 2019)

20. Nash khram. (2018) «Pseudapostles of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church – Moscow Patriarchate want Constantinople to withdraw exarchs from Kyiv», available at: http://nashavira. com.ua/novini/samosvyaty-z-upts-mp-vymagayut-vid-konstantynopolya-vidklykaty-ekzarhiv-zkyyeva/ (access December 25, 2018)

21. Razumkov centre (2017) «Ukrainian citizens’ electoral orientation and attitude towards social institutions: results of sociological survey». available at: http://razumkov.org.ua/ napryamki/sotsiolohichni-doslidzhennia/stavlennia-hromadian-ukrainy-do-suspilnykhinstytutiv-elektoralni-oriientatsii-2 (access December 26, 2018)

22. Tolokolnikova, K. (2017) «Artem Zakharchenko: hate speech use has dramatically decreased in the Ukrainian media», Detector.media, available at: https://detector.media/ infospace/article/122396/2017-01-20-artem-zakharchenko-vikoristannya-movi-vorozhnechiukrainskimi-zmi-duzhe-skorotilosya/ (access December 24, 2018)

23. Union of orthodox journalists (2018) «Volyn population’s opinion on Tomos: alliance is possible only after schismatics’ repentance», available at: https://spzh.news/ua/chelovek-icerkovy/57662-tomos-glazami-volynyan-obedinenije--tolyko-posle-pokajanija-raskolynikov (access November 21, 2018)

24. Spravzhnia Ukraina (2018) «Why Christian symbols provoke hatred in nationalists», available at: http://rukraine.su/2018/02/chomu-hristiyanski-simvoli-viklikayut-nenavist-unatsionalistiv/ (access January 17, 2019)

25. Shchotkina, K. (2014) «Moskovskyi patriarkhat znaishov vynnykh v usikh ukrainskykh bidakh», Delovaya stolica, available at: http://www.dsnews.ua/society/moskovskiy-patriarhatznayshov-vinnih-v-usih-ukrayinskih-05062014165000 (access December 5, 2018)

26. Cerkvarium, available at: https://cerkvarium.org/ (access January 17, 2019)

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.